Protect your freedom!

> Here's the new on-line petition at the Downing Street E-Petitions
> web-site. Please consider signing this:
>
> http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/iplayer/

I've signed it, but I have absolutely no faith in the petitions doing any
good - most petitions don't get a response, and the ones that do always
get a "we're right, you're wrong, we're going to continue doing this
anyway" response.

Personally, I have no interest in iPlayer being available for multiple
platforms - as far as I'm concerned the BBC has a duty to be platform
agnostic and that means using an open standard so that anyone can write a
player for *any* platform. Using a propriatory format and releasing
players for a select few platforms (e.g. Windows, OS X, Linux) is not
"platform agnostic" - what if I want to play it on my phone or some other
device not running one of those OSes?

The BBC keep claiming that they need DRM for content delivered over IP but
that content delivered over DVB should be free-to-air - this doesn't make
any sense to me. You can restrict content delivered over IP to more or
less the same population as the DVB stream covers by restricting delivery
to only UK IP addresses. Sure, someone in the UK can proxy the content
and deliver it to someone outside the UK, but they could do that with DVB
just as easilly anyway.

So from what I can tell, all the reasoning for needing DRM is unfounded -
if you need DRM for IP delivery, why not for DVB too?
lifted off the swlug mailing list

No comment required...